Changes between Version 33 and Version 34 of ticket/1851/General

Timestamp:

2017-03-01T16:29:50+01:00 (7 years ago)

Author:

frrh

Comment:

--

ticket/1851/General

@@ -239 +239 @@
 The only differences are in the qsr_mean values which are uniformly 15 in one file and 95 in the other. All other fields are identical. So this really is a pointless thing to have in the restarts and is just confusing matters by being no reproducible. Ideally we'd ditch it, especially as the NEMO trunk has subsequently completely rewritten this routine, including correcting the setting of llnew. 
 
- 
- 
-
-
-
+Extensive excruciatingly long winded and painstaking use of glob_sub in NEMO leads us to the fact that tsa diverges after the call to sbc_tsc. 
+
+Examining contributing things in sbc_tsc leads us to sfx (salt flux due to melting/freezing) and qns (non solar heat flux). 
+
+These in turn seems to lead us to sbcice_cice which seems to set these up. That in turn suggests CICE or CICE-NEMO coupling is implicated. 
+
+|Now the XCS has crashed everything, so while waiting for that to be sorted out I look at the differences in CICE branches between the coupled and stand alone cases - and there are several! Far too many for comfort or to ignore:
+
+Coupled model CICE branches;
+{{{
+
+branches/dev/frbe/vn5.1.2_sal_dep_frz_fix@1126
+branches/dev/frrh/vn5.1.2_tripole_fix@1237
+
+branches/dev/frsy/vn5.1.2_netcdf4_output@1072
+branches/dev/hadax/r1205_SIMIP_GSI8@1273
+branches/dev/hadci/vn5.1.2_land_suppression@1122
+branches/dev/hadjs/vn5.1.2_avoid_NEMO_units@1059
+branches/dev/hadjs/vn5.1.2_fix_mpond_init_bug@1065
+branches/dev/hadjs/vn5.1.2_sea_ice_salinity@1061
+branches/dev/mandrej/vn5.1.2_mpi_update@1243
+branches/test/hadjs/vn5.1.2_dragio_change@1152
+
+}}}  
+ 
+Non coupled model CICE branches:
+{{{
+branches/dev/frbe/vn5.1.2_GSI7_CCSM3_meltponds@1114
+branches/dev/frbe/vn5.1.2_sal_dep_frz_fix@1126
+branches/dev/frrh/vn5.1.2_tripole_fix@1237
+branches/dev/frsy/vn5.1.2_fix_GSI6_constants_forced_ocean_ice@1070
+branches/dev/frsy/vn5.1.2_netcdf4_output@1072
+branches/dev/hadax/vn5.1.2_GSI8@1141
+branches/dev/hadci/vn5.1.2_land_suppression@1122
+branches/dev/hadjs/vn5.1.2_avoid_NEMO_units@1059
+branches/dev/hadjs/vn5.1.2_fix_mpond_init_bug@1065
+branches/dev/hadjs/vn5.1.2_sea_ice_salinity@1061
+}}}
+ 
+
+So the coupled case has extra branches:
+{{{
+branches/dev/hadax/r1205_SIMIP_GSI8@1273
+branches/dev/mandrej/vn5.1.2_mpi_update@1243
+branches/test/hadjs/vn5.1.2_dragio_change@1152
+}}}
+
+WHile it does not contain
+{{{
+branches/dev/frbe/vn5.1.2_GSI7_CCSM3_meltponds@1114
+branches/dev/frsy/vn5.1.2_fix_GSI6_constants_forced_ocean_ice@1070
+branches/dev/hadax/vn5.1.2_GSI8@1141
+}}}